When can a tenant withhold rent?

Can you withhold rent?

Understanding your rights and responsibilities.

When you decide to rent a property, you enter into a contractual agreement that involves paying rent and maintaining the property throughout the duration of your tenancy. As a tenant, you are entitled to certain rights, including peaceful enjoyment of the property without interference and a property that meets habitable standards.

However, it’s important to note that just because certain repairs or maintenance tasks have not been promptly addressed – such as missing Gas Safety or Energy Performance Certificates – it doesn’t give you the legal right to withhold or reduce your rent payments.

In most cases, you are obligated to pay your rent as agreed upon in the tenancy agreement. There is, however, a specific set of circumstances where you might be justified in withholding some or all of your rent. This situation is outlined under Section 11 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, which places a mandatory duty on landlords to make necessary repairs to both the interior and exterior structure of the property.

If your landlord fails to carry out essential repairs within a “reasonable” timeframe after you’ve reported them, they might be in breach of their obligations. In such cases, you could have the option to carry out the repairs yourself under “common law.” This means you could deduct the repair costs from your rent payments, but only after following a strict set of guidelines known as the “Rules of Set Off.”

The Rules of Set Off involve several steps:

  • Write to your landlord or agent, notifying them of the necessary repair and giving them a reasonable time to address it
  • If you receive no response, repeat the first step and provide an extended period for the repair to be completed
  • Obtain at least two estimates from reputable contractors for the repair cost
  • Send a final written reminder to the landlord with copies of the estimates, giving them another reasonable timeframe to complete the repair
  • If the landlord remains unresponsive, you can hire the contractor with the best estimate to perform the repair. Send the landlord an invoice for payment
  • If the landlord refuses to settle the invoice, you can deduct the repair costs from your rent and provide a written account of the deductions

It’s important to remember that this process can only be used in specific circumstances, and it’s crucial to strictly adhere to the Rules of Set Off. Additionally, the right to withhold rent is limited to repairs required under the Act, and any other deductions must be agreed upon between you and your landlord.

If you choose not to follow this procedure or your situation doesn’t fall under the defined repairing criteria, you should continue paying your rent. In such cases, you can address contractual breaches separately by claiming damages against your landlord for failing to uphold the terms of the tenancy agreement.

In conclusion, legally withholding rent is a complex process that must be followed diligently. It’s important to remember that you cannot withhold rent simply based on the belief that it covers potential damages. If you’re unsure about your rights and responsibilities, consulting with legal experts or tenant advisory services can provide valuable guidance.

Remember, at mydeposits, we cannot assist with deposit disputes if you haven’t paid your rent, even if you believe you’re entitled to damages due to a landlord’s breach of the Tenancy Agreement. For more information and to better understand the legal aspects of rent withholding, consult relevant legal sources and keep a detailed record of events throughout the process.

Download guide